Comparisons

eCommerce agency or freelancer: what really changes for your project

The useful question is not 'which is better': it is which skills the project must cover, for how long, and what happens if the person working on it is unavailable for three weeks.

Let's be upfront about the conflict of interest: this page is written by an agency. That said, we will not use the space to tell you that relying on a single professional is the wrong choice, because it is not: there are projects where a good freelancer is the best possible choice, faster and cheaper, and pretending otherwise would just be an inelegant way of selling.

The useful question is not "which is better". It is: which skills your project must cover, for how long, and what happens if the person working on it is unavailable for three weeks. Once you have those three answers, the choice makes itself. Here are the criteria we would use if we had to choose a supplier for our own eCommerce.

In short

A freelancer is the right choice when:

  • the project needs a single main skill (only development, or only design, or only advertising campaigns);
  • the scope is limited and well defined, with a clear start and end;
  • you already have in-house coordination that knows what to ask for and can judge the work delivered;
  • timing is not critical and the budget is tight;
  • it is a specialist intervention on something that already works.

You need an agency when:

  • you need several skills coordinated with one another (development, marketing, data, strategy) that must speak the same language;
  • the project is ongoing and must hold up over time, not end at delivery;
  • there are integrations or migrations that need different specialists working in parallel;
  • eCommerce is a significant revenue channel and downtime costs you;
  • nobody in your company can coordinate several suppliers and arbitrate when they pass responsibility back and forth.

The seven dimensions to compare

1. Skills covered

A growing eCommerce needs development, interface design, SEO, campaigns, email marketing, data analysis and strategy all at once. No single professional covers all seven well, and anyone who claims to usually does two well and improvises the rest. The excellent freelancer is vertical: that is their strength, not a flaw. The point is that if the project needs four skills, you will have to coordinate four people.

2. Continuity over time

The real risk is not quality, it is availability. A professional who has room for you today may in six months have a bigger client, a different commitment or simply another life. Your store, on the other hand, needs support exactly when something breaks, and you do not choose when that is.

3. Dependence on a single person

In technical jargon this is the bus factor: how many people have to disappear before the project stops. With a freelancer the number is one. If that person is the only one who knows the code, the server access and the custom logic, that knowledge is not documented anywhere and it is a real operational risk, regardless of anyone's skill. It is a legitimate question to ask, and it should be asked of everyone, agencies included.

4. Ability to absorb peaks

Migration, launch, Black Friday, a major campaign. At peak moments you need to be able to put several people on the same problem on the same day. A single professional cannot be in two places, however good they are; an organisation can reallocate.

5. Governance and accountability

With several separate suppliers (one for development, one for campaigns, one for design), the moment something stops working the blame game starts: the developer says the traffic is poor quality, the campaign manager says the site does not convert, and meanwhile you are not selling. With a single accountable contact there is no one to pass the ball to. It is the most concrete advantage of an agency, and it is organisational before it is technical.

6. Real cost, not hourly rate

A freelancer's hourly rate is almost always lower. The cost of the project is not necessarily lower, because the bill must also include the coordination time that falls on you, the risk of rework when skills do not talk to one another, and the indirect cost of idle time. Compare quotes for the same expected result, not for the same number of hours.

7. Process and documentation

This is the most reliable discriminator, and it cuts across the agency/freelancer divide. The right supplier, whatever form it takes, works with traceable tickets, test environments separate from production, versioned code and documented interventions. The wrong supplier works directly in production and keeps everything in their head. This difference matters more than the one between agency and freelancer.

Comparison table

DimensionFreelancerAgency
Skills coveredOne, in depthSeveral, coordinated
Continuity over timeTied to the personTied to the organisation
Dependence on one personHighSpread across the team
Handling peaksLimitedSeveral people in parallel
Hourly rateLowerHigher
Coordination costYoursAbsorbed by the supplier
Responsibility for the resultWithin their own scopeFor the whole project
Best suited toWell-defined interventionsOngoing projects
Speed on small tasksVery highMedium, goes through the process

There is also a third way (and it is the most common)

In practice, most projects are neither one nor the other. The mixed models that really work are three:

  • In-house team + external partner. The company manages content, catalogue and orders; the external partner handles development, enhancements and technical oversight. It is the most balanced model for established companies.
  • Agency on the project, freelancers on vertical activities. An organisation as the reference point for architecture and coordination, external specialists for very specific tasks. It works if someone is genuinely at the helm.
  • Freelancer for the first launch, agency for growth. Very common: you start lean to validate, and add structure when volumes justify it. It works well on one condition: that the initial work is documented and the code is accessible, otherwise the handover becomes a rebuild.

Want an opinion on your specific case?

Thirty minutes, with no sales pitch: you tell us about your situation and we tell you how we read it.

No commitment: if now is not the right time, we will tell you.

Questions to ask before you sign (to anyone)

They apply to us as much as to anyone else. If a supplier gets irritated by these questions, you already have your answer:

  1. Who will actually work on my project and who is my point of contact when I have a problem?
  2. What happens if the person working on the project is unavailable?
  3. Are the code and access mine? Can I take them away if I change supplier?
  4. How do you track requests and interventions? Is there a history I can consult?
  5. Do you work on a test environment separate from production?
  6. What response times can I count on for support?
  7. What is NOT included in this quote?

How we work, in practice

We are a lean team: development and marketing work in the same room and on the same project, not as separate suppliers who pass responsibility back and forth. On the technical side we are a PrestaShop Expert ★★★ certified agency and have been building eCommerce since 2011; we also develop on Shopify when it is the right platform for the project.

The way we work comes down to four concrete points, which are also the criteria you can use to assess us:

  • A single point of contact, not an anonymous ticket: you know who to call and that person knows your project.
  • Everything tracked: requests, interventions and decisions go through a system you can consult, not through scattered messages.
  • The code is yours. Access, repositories and environments remain your property, always.
  • Response times agreed according to the plan you choose, put in writing before we start and not promised verbally.

We are not the right choice for everyone: if your project is a limited intervention on a single skill, a good individual professional will cost you less and we will tell you so. Our ground is the ongoing project, where the eCommerce channel weighs on revenue. If you want to see where we would start, look at how we approach an eCommerce that is already running and needs to grow or a store that is not performing as it should.

Further reading

Frequently asked questions

A freelancer's hourly rate is almost always lower. The total cost of the project depends on how many skills you need and how much coordination time falls on you: on a single-skill project the freelancer costs less, while on an ongoing multi-skill project the gap narrows or reverses.

Yes, and it is a model that works well if responsibilities are defined in writing and a single party coordinates. The problem is not working side by side: it is ambiguity over who answers for what.

Look at the process, not the portfolio. Ask how they track requests, whether they work on a test environment, whether the code stays yours and what is not included in the quote. The answers to these four questions say more than ten projects on show.

You should never lose it, and it is a condition to put in black and white before you start: code, access and data must stay your property. If a supplier is vague on this point, that vagueness is your answer.

It depends on the support contract, not on the supplier's legal form. The question to ask is what response times are provided and during which time slots: they must be agreed according to the plan you choose and put in writing.

Continue with

Choosing the right technology

The variables that really decide the choice of platform.
Read →

PrestaShop and Shopify compared

The direct comparison between the two most discussed platforms.
Compare →

All comparisons

Back to the index of eCommerce comparisons.
Go to the index →

Want to start from your own eCommerce data?

With Shop Analyzer you can analyse your online store yourself and see what emerges, before you even speak to us.

No commitment: if now is not the right time, we will tell you.

Have a question about a specific case?

Write to us: we reply with our reading of the situation, with no sales steps.

No automatic quotes: first we work out whether we can be of use to you.