PrestaShop vs Shopify: the differences that matter on a real project
It is not a matter of taking sides: they are two opposite models of cost and control, and the difference shows in the third year, not on day one.
Updated July 2026 · by the Zeno Web technical team
Anyone searching for "PrestaShop or Shopify" has usually already understood the easy part: they are two good platforms, both handle billions of euros in sales, and anyone who says one of them is objectively superior is selling something. The hard part is different: the two platforms have opposite economic models and opposite models of control, and this difference does not show on the first day. It shows in the third year, when the catalogue has grown, the integrations with the ERP have arrived, and you realise that some choices can no longer be reversed without starting over.
On this page we compare PrestaShop and Shopify on the points that really determine the cost and freedom of a project over time: licence, recurring costs, customisation, integrations, updates, SEO and exit. If you are still further upstream and also considering other technologies, it makes more sense to start with the method for choosing an eCommerce platform.
In short: when PrestaShop makes sense and when Shopify does
PrestaShop makes sense when:
- the catalogue is complex: many variants, combinations, attributes, price lists differentiated by customer or by group;
- you need B2B logic: custom prices, minimum quantities, tiered discounts, orders by customer code;
- the store must talk to an ERP, management system or WMS already in use, with non-standard synchronisation rules;
- you want to own the code and not depend on the commercial policies of a single vendor;
- sales volume is high and sales commissions significantly affect your margin.
Shopify makes sense when:
- the catalogue is simple and well normalised, with few variants per product;
- the priority is time-to-market: selling early, validating the market, reducing initial risk;
- you neither have nor want in-house technical oversight and prefer infrastructure, security and updates to be someone else's problem;
- the business model is D2C with a strong marketing push and the value lies in the ecosystem of apps and sales channels rather than in custom logic;
- you accept working within the platform's limits in exchange for stability and speed.
If you recognise yourself in both columns, that is not a contradiction: it is the typical case where the choice must be made by looking at the numbers, not at preferences. The following sections are for exactly that.
Licence model: what you own in one case and in the other
PrestaShop is open source software. You install it on hosting of your choice, the source code is yours, you can modify it, change it, take it away with you. Nobody can unilaterally change the rules of the game: if tomorrow you are unhappy with your supplier, you change supplier and the store stays where it is. The flip side is that responsibility for the infrastructure is yours: servers, security, backups, updates, module compatibility. It is not a problem, but it is work, and it must be budgeted.
Shopify is SaaS. You do not own the software: you pay to use it. You do not manage servers, you do not worry about security patches, you do not update anything by hand. In return you accept that the rules (available features, commercial terms, payment policies, product evolution) are decided by a third party. Your store lives in someone else's house, and that is a legitimate trade-off, as long as it is a conscious choice and not a later discovery.
This is the difference all the others stem from. It is not ideology: it is the structure of the contractual relationship, and it is what changes most as the project grows.
Costs: what you really pay in the first three years
Comparing the two list prices is the worst way to think about the costs of an eCommerce. What matters is the total cost of ownership (TCO) over a horizon of at least 36 months. The items are these, and they must be filled in for your real case.
Cost items on PrestaShop
- Initial development: the highest item. Theme, customisations, integrations, data migration.
- Hosting and infrastructure: a recurring cost, varying with traffic and catalogue size.
- Third-party modules: one-off or annual licences.
- Ongoing development and updates: the item almost everyone forgets when getting a quote and almost everyone discovers in the second year.
- No sales commission to the platform: you only pay the commissions of the payment gateway you choose.
Cost items on Shopify
- Monthly or annual subscription for the plan you choose.
- Apps with recurring fees: this is where the real cost swells. On a mature store, the sum of monthly apps often exceeds the platform subscription itself.
- Transaction fees: they vary with the plan and the payment system used. This is the item to calculate on YOUR expected sales, because it scales with revenue: the more you sell, the more you pay.
- Theme development and customisations: lower than on PrestaShop, but not zero.
- No hosting, security or update costs: they are included.
Below a certain sales threshold Shopify's cost structure is lighter; above that threshold, sales commissions tip the calculation in favour of PrestaShop. Exactly where that threshold lies depends on your margin per order, not on an industry average.
Customisation: where "it can be done" ends
Catalogue, variants and pricing logic
Here the gap is wider than it seems from the demos. PrestaShop comes with a very granular handling of combinations, attributes, features and customer groups, and above all it is extensible: if the logic you need does not exist, it can be built. Shopify has a variant model that is more rigid by design: it works very well as long as your catalogue fits into it, and becomes a workaround exercise when it does not. The point is not which is more powerful, it is whether YOUR catalogue fits the model. It is a check that takes half a day of analysis, and it must be done before choosing, not after.
Checkout, shipping and payment rules
The checkout is the part of the site that generates revenue and also the one where the two platforms differ most sharply in freedom. On PrestaShop the purchase flow is deeply customisable: fields, steps, conditional rules, non-standard shipping logic. On Shopify the checkout is a protected and standardised area: highly optimised, very fast, but with room for intervention defined by the platform and the plan you subscribe to. If your sales model has particular rules (thresholds, constraints, documents, authorisations), this point alone can decide the choice.
Integrations with ERP, management systems and logistics
In structured projects the eCommerce is never an island: it talks to the management system for customer records, stock and orders, sometimes to a WMS, often to a CRM and to the email marketing platform.
On PrestaShop the integration can be built to measure: you write a connector that speaks the language of your existing management system, with the synchronisation rules you need. It requires development, but has no conceptual limits.
On Shopify you work through APIs and available connectors: when a connector for your management system already exists the path is quick and proven; when it does not, or when it exists but does not cover your flow, you still need development on external middleware.
The right question is not "does it integrate?" (it always does). It is: how much does it cost to maintain that integration when one of the two sides is updated? We have a precise position on this, which we describe on the page dedicated to eCommerce development on PrestaShop and on the one about projects built on Shopify.
Updates and lifecycle: the time factor
PrestaShop 8.2 in extended support, PrestaShop 9 as the horizon
This is a concrete, datable fact, not an opinion: PrestaShop 8.2.x entered extended support in July 2025, while PrestaShop 9 is the platform's long-term path. In operational terms: if you are starting a new project today, the question of which version branch to start from has a direct impact on the costs of the next three years. If instead you already have a store in production on an older version, upgrading is not a box to tick: it is a project involving module compatibility analysis, theme rebuilding and testing. We talk about it openly because it is the cost item most often underestimated, by us as by anyone else.
How updates work on Shopify
They do not work: they happen. The platform updates itself, without you having to plan anything, and it is a real advantage that is worth a lot in avoided maintenance. The flip side is that Shopify decides the updates: if a feature changes or a third-party app stops being maintained, you adapt. It is not a catastrophic risk, but it is a risk you do not control.
Want to start from your own eCommerce data?
With Shop Analyzer you can analyse your online store yourself and see what emerges, before you even speak to us.
No commitment: if now is not the right time, we will tell you.
SEO and performance: is there a real difference?
Less than the two camps claim. Both platforms allow serious technical SEO: clean URLs, title and description management, canonicals, structured data, sitemaps, multilingual handling.
The real differences are two, and they are operational rather than technical:
- Control. On PrestaShop you have access to every level of the HTML output and can intervene on anything, including URL architectures and pagination and faceted navigation logic. On Shopify some URL structures are imposed by the platform and cannot be touched.
- Starting speed. On Shopify you start from an already excellent technical base without doing anything. On PrestaShop performance is a result you achieve through configuration, suitable hosting and work on the theme: you get just as high, but you get there by working.
In both cases the factor that weighs most on the organic result is not the platform: it is the quality of the information architecture and the content. That is the work we do in our eCommerce SEO service, and it applies identically on both technologies.
Migrating from one to the other: what it really involves
It happens often, in both directions, and it needs to be said clearly: a migration is not a move, it is a rebuild.
What carries over without much drama: catalogue, categories, customer records, order history, editorial content.
What does NOT carry over and must be redone: the theme (which is platform-specific code, not a transferable file), modules and apps (which are different, incompatible ecosystems), integrations with external systems, and, critically, the URL structure, which must be mapped with 301 redirects one by one if you do not want to throw away years of rankings.
The right moment to consider a migration is when your current platform is costing you more than it earns you, not when someone convinces you that "the other one is better". If your store is already online and you are weighing this scenario, the starting point is an analysis of the state of your already-running eCommerce.
Comparison table
| Criterion | PrestaShop | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Open source, self-hosted | SaaS subscription |
| Code ownership | Yours | The vendor's |
| Initial cost | Higher | Lower |
| Recurring costs | Hosting + maintenance | Subscription + apps + commissions |
| Sales commissions | None to the platform | Present, vary by plan |
| Customisation | No conceptual limits | Within the platform's limits |
| Checkout | Deeply customisable | Standardised and protected |
| Complex catalogue and B2B | Strong point | Possible with adaptations |
| Custom ERP integration | Custom, without constraints | Via API and connectors |
| Technical maintenance | Yours | Included |
| Time-to-market | Longer | Faster |
| Leaving the platform | You take everything with you | A rebuild is needed |
How we reach the decision with you
We do not have a preferred platform to sell. We are a PrestaShop Expert ★★★ certified agency and have been developing since 2011, which gives us a technical depth on PrestaShop that we do not improvise; we also develop on Shopify, and when it is the right choice for the project we say so without any problem.
The process we follow is always the same, and it takes more listening than presenting: we map the real catalogue and its exceptions, list the external systems the store will have to talk to, quantify the expected sales to calculate the impact of commissions, and check who will run the store day to day after launch. From those four answers the platform almost chooses itself.
If you do not yet know who will look after the project over time, that is a decision that weighs as much as the technology choice: we cover it in the comparison between relying on an agency or on an individual professional.
Further reading
- Choosing a Shopify Partner: how to evaluate a Shopify partner for a small or medium business.
Frequently asked questions
The software is free and open source, but the project is not. You pay for hosting, development, any modules and maintenance. "Free" refers to the software licence, not to the cost of the store.
At the start, almost always. Over time it depends on sales volume: the subscription is fixed, but sales commissions and app fees grow with revenue, while on PrestaShop recurring costs are more stable. The comparison only makes sense over a horizon of at least three years.
Yes, if the migration includes a complete URL mapping with 301 redirects and the content architecture is kept. A temporary dip in the first few weeks is normal; a structural loss is not, and is a symptom of a badly done migration.
Shopify starts faster with no intervention. PrestaShop reaches equivalent or better performance with suitable hosting, cache configuration and a well-built theme. The difference lies in the work required, not in the ceiling that can be reached.
In the vast majority of cases PrestaShop, because the handling of customer groups, differentiated price lists and pricing rules is native and extensible. On Shopify it is possible, but it requires higher plans or dedicated apps, with recurring costs that must be factored in.
Both. We are a PrestaShop Expert ★★★ certified agency and have developed on PrestaShop since 2011; we also deliver Shopify projects. We choose the platform after the analysis, not before.
Continue with
How to choose an eCommerce platform
Agency or freelancer: who carries the project forward
Want an opinion on your specific case?
Thirty minutes, with no sales pitch: you tell us about your situation and we tell you how we read it.
No commitment: if now is not the right time, we will tell you.
